Questions emerge about the validity of the calls outside Belfast and attention is drawn elsewhere where parallel secret negotiations seem to be happening with the mysterious leader and main owner of Shergar, the Aga Khan.
But nothing can stop the rumour mill from churning and there are reports Shergar is in Libya with Gadaffi and also that he has been taken by the New Orleans mafia.
It becomes impossible to separate fact from fiction.
Published on Tuesday, 1st June 2021.
Available Podcasts from Sport's Strangest Crimes
Subscribe to Sport's Strangest Crimes
We are not the BBC, we only list available podcasts. To find out more about the programme including episodes available on BBC iPlayer, go to the Sport's Strangest Crimes webpage.